Showing posts with label bachelor certificate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bachelor certificate. Show all posts

Saturday, September 24, 2022

How Successful, and Micro, are Micro-credential Programs?


The government of the Canadian province of Alberta has announced a CA$8M, two year micro-credential program. This follows a CA$5.6M 2021 pilot program. But how successful was the pilot? How much shorter, cheaper, and successful are the micro-credentials, compared to existing vocational and university short qualifications? Do these help disadvantaged students, or primarily help those already better off?

Who Gets the Help?

I was unable to find any report on the outcomes of Alberta's pilot microcredentials program. It would be useful to know the completion rate for low socioeconomic status students. Also a useful rubric would be the increase in income of graduates, compared to those who undertook existing conventional short vocational and university qualifications. 

One of the problems which has occurred with previous initiatives, such as Distance Education, and Massive open online courses (MOOCS), is that they tend to benifit those who are already well off, and well credentialed. Funding bodies, and educational institutions tend to underestimate the resources needed, and the cost of supporting the students who need the help. 

How micro are the microcredentials? 

The previous Australian government talked about microcredentials, but what they actually funded were conventional 12 week vocational & university certificates. Those are useful qualifications, but were not really new, or micro, credentials. The Australian government funded six month undergraduate certificates. These were a new credential, but were mostly implemented by universities packaging up existing courses from the first semester of a degree. That allowed for rapid implementation, and nesting with degrees, but not much in the way of helping disadvantaged students, or addressing new industry needs,

Wednesday, May 12, 2021

Australian Budget to Popularize Shorter Courses at Private Providers and Online Learning

The 2021‑22 Federal Budget contained some measure related to higher education. Of particular interest are two relatively small amounts for increased short courses and offshore education:

"$26.1 million over four years from 2021-22 to assist non-university higher education providers to attract more domestic students through offering 5,000 additional short course places in 2021

• $9.4 million in 2021-22 to provide grants of up to $150,000 to eligible higher education and English language providers to support innovative online and offshore education delivery models"

From Budget Paper Number 2, Part 1: Receipt Measures, Australian Government, 18 May 2021, URL: https://budget.gov.au/2021-22/content/bp2/download/bp2_02_receipt.pdf#page=7

Short Courses Opening Up Higher Education to Private Providers?

The "short courses" referred to are not that short, being bachelor and graduate certificates, which require one semester (about 12 weeks full time) to complete. These have proved popular with students and I think they are a good idea. But I am not sure universities like students getting the idea a six months course will do to get a job, rather than a three year degree. Also universities will have to cope with students turning up years later and ask for a semester's credit off a degree for having completed a certificate. This is not unreasonable as the certificates, at least the initial ones, were created by universities repackaging courses from existing degrees.

However, what might cause universities most concern is that this additional funding is only for non-universities. Apart from direct competition for students, this may create a demand for students from these non-universities for credit at universities. 

Innovative online and offshore education delivery models?

The small allocation of funding for "innovative online and offshore education delivery models" might be useful beyond the English language providers it is targeted at. Australian education providers have a problem with international students unable to get to Australia, due to COVID-19.  This may become worse, far worse, if current relations with China deteriorate further. Australian higher education providers, not just for English courses, need to urgently find new ways to deliver programs and to new markets. Australian universities also need to provide more attractive flexible delivery methods, as students do not want to come to campus every day, and may decide to study elsewhere. 

Tuesday, November 17, 2020

Designing University Courseware for Micro-credentials and Courses So Students Do the Work

The Australian government has encouraged universities to offer shorter qualifications to provide vocational skills which are in demand, in areas such as cyber security. This includes certificates (taking about 12 weeks full time study) and microcredentials (around 3 weeks, or less). This requires getting students focused on study quickly, as there is not time to waste on an orientation week, or students wandering around finding out what to do. Also learning designers can't afford to spend as much time on a short program as a lone one.

When I first tried teaching online, a decade ago, I tried to emulate a face to face lectures and tutorials. This is a mistake many first time online teachers make, as these are the only formats they are familiar with. Lectures and tutorials are not a very effective teaching techniques, offline or online. 

The approach I developed over ten years teaching online was to design first for pure asynchronous online delivery, then add synchronous components, which could alternatively be delivered face to face. This approach could be extended to micro-credentials which could then be used for conventional courses in a certificate.

What every teacher has to keep in mind is that the task is not to work very hard, it is to get the student to work very hard. Some teachers respond to students who don't seem to be learning by talking at them more, which makes the situation worse. Instead they have to set goals for the students. The only way I have found to do this is with assessment: if you want a student to do something, give them marks for it.

So we first have to set learning objectives for the microcredential or course (preferably based on external widely recognized standards, not something developed at the university), then translate these into assessment tasks, then provide activities for students to learn the skills and knowledge required and lastly provide materials to help. Most of the budget of student learning time should be taken up with individual and group activities, not time spent in "class". Most of the budget for instructor time should be for helping student with their assessed tasks, not giving presentations or leading discussions.